How to read a history dossier
A field guide to testing a year against the wording, the calendar and the evidence, using four completed AnnoGame puzzles.
Start with the word that carries the date
Cover the year on a completed dossier and underline just one verb. Does a court send a traveler, does the traveler arrive, or does a chronicler record the journey? A perfectly good date for one of those actions can be a poor answer for another. A useful first guess is a sentence rather than a number: “I am dating the departure, not the return.” Only then put a year next to it. After the reveal, keep the sentence and change the number. If you have to change the verb as well, you have found the reason the clue was difficult.
A practice pair: one year, two different stories
In the August 7 dossier, a Dutch charter and a Scottish king's succession to the English throne land in adjacent years. Try sketching the pair as two lines rather than as one arrow. On the first line put a legal instrument and the organization it creates. On the second put a person and the two royal titles he holds. The first event does not explain the second. Their closeness makes them useful memory neighbors, but a timeline is not evidence of cause. Now turn over your notes and reconstruct which line belongs to 1602. Naming the kind of change is a stronger test than recognizing either number.
Separate the answer from the precision of the evidence
Compare the two ancient entries in the September 2 dossier. A question about administrative tablets asks you to locate a practice in a period. It does not ask for the year in which one named scribe wrote one surviving tablet. Try replacing “during” with “on the first day of.” If that makes the sentence absurd, treat its displayed year as a chronological anchor. Keep the anchor for the game; keep the qualification when explaining the history to someone else. A rounded answer in a puzzle is not a discovery that an archaeological period began on a particular January morning.
Count through the calendar boundary
Make a strip of paper with four marks: 2 BC, 1 BC, AD 1, AD 2. Count the spaces, not the marks. There are three intervals, not four; the conventional historical labels skip year zero. Now use the same strip to place a traveler leaving the Han court before a voyage sponsored by Henry VII in the September 28 dossier. For an estimate you do not need to count every year. You do need to decide which side of the boundary each event belongs to before measuring the distance. This is a reading exercise, not a new rule for calculating game points.
Read a source with a question in hand
Follow the source beside an answer with one task: locate the passage that supports the combination of actor, action and year. Searching just for the year can land on a bibliography, an anniversary or the end of a long process. Searching just for the actor can land on a birth date. Once you find a candidate passage, read the sentence on either side. Does the account distinguish a decision from its implementation? Does the author call a date approximate? Record the wording in your own words and keep the link. A revision link identifies the text that was consulted; it is not a promise that every sentence in that text is settled history.
Build an interval rather than memorize a list
The October 24 dossier puts three early nineteenth-century events within nine years. Draw that short span wide enough to write on. Put the British legislative act at one end and the unusual summer at the other. Fit the battle between them, then step back and ask whether the same scale would leave room on the paper for the Treaty of Versailles. It probably would not. Make a second, coarser timeline instead of squeezing the later events into the margin. Moving between the two scales is the skill: one tells you which near neighbors are easy to reverse; the other distinguishes a century from a decade.
Keep a record of what would change your mind
On a second reading, give each missed answer a short diagnosis. “Right actor, wrong milestone” calls for rewriting a verb. “Right century, reversed neighbors” calls for a comparison pair. “Assumed an exact year” calls for a note about evidence. These are private study notes; you do not need to share a score or provide a nickname to use them. For a disputed answer, send the dossier date, the exact clue, the source passage and the alternative interpretation through Contact. An explanation of which event a different year describes is much easier to check than a bare replacement number.
Try the method without looking ahead
Choose a completed file from the archive, not today's sealed game. Read one clue aloud, write your sentence and estimate, then read its reveal and source. Come back the next day and explain that single event without using its year. If a listener could still tell what happened and what did not happen, you now have an anchor worth attaching a date to. If the description could fit three different milestones, sharpen it before attempting another round.